Ep 17. The Supremes

The West Wing season 5 episode 17, titled "The Supremes," follows President Bartlet as he faces the challenge of nominating two Supreme Court justices. In order to secure the confirmation of the nominees, the White House staff must work to gain the support of key senators who could swing the vote.

The episode revolves around the confirmation hearings of Judge Evelyn Baker Lang and Judge Christopher Mulready, who are both nominated to the Supreme Court by President Bartlet. The White House staff is split as to which nominee should be prioritized, with some believing that Judge Lang would be the easier confirmation while others argue that Judge Mulready is the better nominee.

As the confirmation process unfolds, the staff must work to navigate the political pressures and negotiations that come with filling two seats on the nation's highest court. Meanwhile, the judges themselves are put under intense scrutiny by the Senate Judiciary Committee, with their personal and professional lives dissected in public view.

Alongside the confirmation hearings, the episode also touches on several subplots, including Toby and Sam's attempts to prevent a congressman from blocking a foreign aid bill, and President Bartlet's ongoing feud with Speaker of the House Haffley.

"The Supremes" is a standout episode of The West Wing for many reasons. It tackles complex issues surrounding the Supreme Court nomination process, including the role of politics and public opinion in the decision-making process. It also highlights the political wrangling and backroom deals that go on behind the scenes in Washington, D.C.

The performances of the cast are particularly noteworthy in this episode, with guest stars Glenn Close and William Fichtner both turning in strong performances as the two judges. Their interactions with the staff and senators bring a depth and complexity to their characters, and add tension and drama to the overall plotline.

Overall, "The Supremes" is a compelling and thought-provoking episode of The West Wing. It showcases the strengths of the series, including its sharp writing, talented cast, and nuanced storylines. For fans of the show, it is a must-see episode, and for those new to the series, it is a perfect introduction to the world of The West Wing.