Ep 22. Isaac and Ishmael

Isaac and Ishmael is a unique and standalone episode of The West Wing, Season 3. It is not part of the main storyline but addresses the events that took place in America a few weeks after the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001. The episode is a dialogue-driven drama that seeks to create an understanding of the complexities of terrorism and the war on terror.

The episode begins with a terrorist attack at a nearby school that many of the White House employees' children attend. The building is evacuated, and all the children's lives are ultimately spared. However, the experience lingers, leaving many traumatized. The attack inspires a series of conversations among reporters, students, and White House staff. Soon the scene shifts to the White House, where the President and three of his key staff members' students are trapped inside the Situation Room.

The President and his team are joined by a group of young Muslim students who have been brought to the White House for a tour. What follows is a series of deep conversations exploring various aspects of terrorism and its impact on society.

Josh, the President's senior staff, struggles with a sense of hopelessness that has overtaken him since the attacks. Toby, another senior staffer, attempts to help Josh gain some perspective by exploring the roots of terrorism. Meanwhile, the President engages with the young Muslim students, answering their questions with candor, sensitivity, and patience.

Throughout the episode, the dialogue between all the characters is thought-provoking and sparks reflection, especially for viewers who remember the aftermath of 9/11. The conversation moves from the root causes of terrorism to the impact of America's foreign policy in the Middle East. There are also discussions on the difference between Islam and terrorism and how xenophobia and hatred can easily perpetuate without sufficient understanding.

The episode explores the theme of tolerance, mutual understanding, and the complex political issues surrounding terrorism. The dialogue is respectful, nuanced, and non-judgmental in its exploration of these issues.

Overall, Isaac and Ishmael is a powerful and poignant examination of the roots of terrorism, its impact, and America's response in the aftermath of 9/11. The episode is thoughtful and thought-provoking, making it a memorable addition to the West Wing's repertoire. While it may not be compelling for fans solely interested in the show's ongoing narrative, it is an essential episode that offers an insightful psychological examination of the country's feelings in the immediate aftermath of 9/11.