Ep 5. History Fair

In Rutherford Falls season one, episode five, titled "History Fair," Nathan Rutherford (Ed Helms) tries to convince a stubborn high school history teacher, Ms. Freeley (Jana Schmieding), to include more Native American history in the school curriculum. Nathan, who is trying to preserve his family's legacy in the town, feels a deep obligation to include Native American history in the program since they are co-founders of the town. The episode highlights the challenges of creating a culturally sensitive curriculum that is inclusive of all minority groups.

Meanwhile, Reagan Wells (Jesse Leigh) is preparing for the Rutherford Falls High School's History Fair, where students are invited to showcase their projects. Reagan, a student of Native American descent, faces a dilemma when she realizes that her project topic, which is about the Native American figure "Sitting Bull," might be offensive due to cultural appropriation. Reagan navigates her way through the sensitive topic while trying to remain true to her own heritage while not offending others.

Throughout the episode, Nathan and Reagan work together to navigate the complexities of cultural sensitivity and inclusion. As Nathan and Ms. Freeley go toe-to-toe over the curriculum, he learns important lessons about the often-overlooked history of the people who have lived on the land before him. Meanwhile, Reagan provides an important perspective on how cultural appropriation can often miss the mark when it comes to honoring one's cultural heritage.

As Nathan and Reagan's stories converge, we see how difficult it can be to create a curriculum that is both inclusive and historically accurate. With the help of others in the community, including Reagan's mother (Michael Greyeyes) and Nathan's best friend (Dustin Milligan), the two lesson planners learn from each other as they navigate their way forward to create the best possible curriculum for their students.

"History Fair" is a thought-provoking episode that highlights the need for inclusivity and cultural sensitivity towards Native American history. The show's clever writing and dynamic characters create a compelling and nuanced narrative that doesn't pull any punches in its critique of cultural insensitivity. Nathan and Reagan's storylines are a testament to the show's ability to blend humor and heart with important issues surrounding inclusivity and cultural awareness.