Ep 3. The Code

In Reasonable Doubt season 2 episode 3, entitled "The Code," co-hosts Melissa Lewkowicz and Chris Anderson take on a new, complex case. The episode starts with the introduction of Michael Welsh, a young man who has been convicted of killing his best friend, Mark Fisher, in 2002. The case is unusual as Welsh has already been released from prison due to the lack of forensic evidence tying him to the crime. However, he is still considered guilty in the eyes of the law.

The co-hosts of the show start their investigation by meeting with Michael Welsh himself, who is eager to clear his name. Welsh explains how he feels responsible for Fisher's death, as they were both involved in illegal activities such as drugs and gun running. He mentions a dispute that arose between him and Fisher's family, which led to him being pinned for the murder. Welsh maintains his innocence throughout the episode and pleads with Lewkowicz and Anderson to help him fight for justice.

In their pursuit of the truth, Lewkowicz and Anderson visit Fisher's family to gather more information about the case. They meet with Fisher's sister and father, who are still grieving their loved one's death and harbour feelings of anger towards Welsh. Through the interviews, the co-hosts discover a series of clues and inconsistencies in the original testimony which prompt further investigation.

The episode progresses as Anderson delves deep into the forensic reports, scrutinising every detail of the evidence presented in the case. He examines witness statements, forensic reports and crime scene photos searching for any details that could clear Welsh's name. Anderson uncovers new evidence, which could potentially exonerate Welsh and prove his innocence.

Meanwhile, Lewkowicz visits Welsh's mother, who reveals details about her son's life before the crime occurred. She describes that Welsh was always an honest boy and would never commit a crime, let alone murder his friend. Lewkowicz, touched by her words, promises to fight for Welsh's freedom until justice prevails.

As the episode comes to an end, Lewkowicz and Anderson present the new evidence to specialist lawyers who review the case and determine that a new trial may be possible. The lawyers are impressed with the evidence presented and agree to take on Welsh's case, offering hope to the family and Michael who has waited for justice for over 20 years.

In this episode, Reasonable Doubt demonstrates the justice system's pitfalls and highlights the importance of examining legal cases from every angle, ensuring that justice prevails. It also shows how a small misstep in gathering the evidence can result in an innocent person being convicted. The co-hosts exploit the flaws in the justice system and bring to light the need for a more transparent and unbiased legal system. Despite the emotional nature of the case, the co-hosts handle it with care and sensitivity, allowing viewers to witness the complexities involved in a legal dispute.