Ep 9. Failure to Remember

In Reasonable Doubt season 1 episode 9, titled "Failure to Remember," former homicide detective Chris Anderson partners with criminal defense attorney Melissa Lewkowicz to investigate a potential wrongful conviction case.

The episode begins with Anderson and Lewkowicz meeting with a man named Charles who has spent over 20 years in prison for a murder he claims he did not commit. Despite being convicted solely on eyewitness testimony, there are discrepancies in the testimony and the evidence does not directly link Charles to the crime. Anderson and Lewkowicz dig deeper into the case, interviewing witnesses and looking over old evidence, to determine if Charles was wrongly convicted.

Their investigation leads them to a woman named Barbara, who was present at the crime scene and has key information about the case. However, Barbara suffers from memory loss due to health issues, and her recollection of events is unreliable. Anderson and Lewkowicz struggle to piece together the truth, knowing that their findings could ultimately lead to Charles' release or his continued imprisonment.

As they continue their investigation, Anderson and Lewkowicz face pushback from the original investigators who have since retired but are still invested in the outcome of the case. The two must navigate the complex dynamics of the justice system and the emotional toll of potentially overturning a conviction.

Throughout the episode, Anderson and Lewkowicz offer insight into their investigative process, highlighting the importance of thoroughly examining evidence and questioning witness testimony. They also reflect on the greater implications of wrongful convictions and how the justice system can fail individuals.

"Failure to Remember" is a compelling and thought-provoking episode that delves into the complexities of the criminal justice system and the importance of seeking justice, even in cases that may seem closed.