Ep 8. Mennonite Madness

People Magazine Investigates is a documentary series that explores some of the most intriguing and shocking crime stories that have made headlines over the years. In season 6, episode 8, titled "Mennonite Madness," the show examines the brutal murder of a Mennonite family in rural Kentucky.

On a sweltering summer night in 2018, the quiet town of West Liberty was rocked by a gruesome crime. The bodies of four members of the Moore family were discovered in their home by a relative who was worried about their welfare. The victims, identified as Christopher and Gracie Moore, their daughter Whitney, and her boyfriend Joey Roof, had been shot to death.

The investigation that followed was complex and challenging for law enforcement officials, who had to navigate the unique cultural and religious practices of the Mennonite community while trying to piece together what happened on the night of the murders. The killing of the Moore family sent shockwaves through the Mennonite community, which is known for its pacifist beliefs and peaceful way of life.

"Mennonite Madness" takes viewers inside the investigation and examines the various theories that were considered by law enforcement officials. One of the most compelling leads came from an unlikely source - a letter written by an anonymous individual who claimed to have information about the killings. The letter was postmarked from Canada and promised to reveal the identity of the killer in exchange for a cash reward.

As investigators worked to verify the authenticity of the letter, they also began to look into the personal lives of the victims. This led them to uncover a web of secrets and lies that had been lurking beneath the surface of the seemingly idyllic family. From financial troubles to infidelity, the Moores had a laundry list of issues that could have motivated someone to commit such a heinous crime.

The episode features interviews with law enforcement officials who were involved in the investigation, as well as friends and family members of the victims. Viewers will get a glimpse into the unique customs and practices of the Mennonite community, including their aversion to technology and their reluctance to cooperate with law enforcement.

Ultimately, "Mennonite Madness" is a gripping true crime story that will have viewers on the edge of their seats. The episode shines a light on a tragic event that forever changed the lives of those involved and reminds us that even the most peaceful communities are not immune to violence.