Ep 2. In Defiance Of Evil

In Defiance Of Evil is the second episode in the 19th season of On The Case With Paula Zahn. This episode tells the story of the disappearance of a 13-year-old girl, Brenda Sue Schaefer, from Louisville, Kentucky. The case gained national attention as it was proven that the young girl had been brutally murdered by her ex-boyfriend, Mel Ignatow, but he had managed to avoid any punishment for the heinous crime.

The episode begins by introducing Brenda Sue Schaefer, a kind-hearted and beautiful teenager who had her whole life ahead of her. However, on the night of September 22, 1988, Brenda disappeared, leaving her family and friends devastated and heartbroken. Paula Zahn gives viewers an in-depth look at the investigation that took place, including the search for her whereabouts and the interviewing of potential suspects.

As the investigation continues, the focus turns to the ex-boyfriend of Brenda, Mel Ignatow. Paula Zahn details his suspicious behavior and begins to connect him to the case, as his alibis don't quite add up. After being interrogated multiple times by police, Ignatow begins to crack and admits to murdering Brenda. As more evidence is uncovered, it becomes clear that Ignatow had been planning Brenda's murder for quite some time, with a diary that he kept detailing his plans.

Despite his confession and evidence against him, Ignatow manages to avoid a life sentence through a plea deal that was offered by prosecutors. This plea deal caused outrage among the community and Brenda's family, who felt that justice had not been served. Paula Zahn takes viewers through the trial and the subsequent events that took place, including Ignatow's eventual prosecution for perjury and his eventual imprisonment.

In Defiance Of Evil offers viewers an insight into the devastating impact that a senseless and brutal crime can have on a family and community. Paula Zahn highlights the importance of perseverance and determination when it comes to solving crimes and bringing justice to those who have been affected by them. The episode also highlights the flaws within the justice system and how plea deals can hinder the pursuit of true justice.

Overall, In Defiance Of Evil is a poignant and thought-provoking episode that showcases the importance of investigative journalism and exposes the potential pitfalls of the justice system. Paula Zahn presents the case with empathy and understanding, giving viewers an intimate look into the lives of those affected by the crime.