Ep 16. History Repeats Itself

On The Case With Paula Zahn is a true crime documentary series that profiles real-life murder cases and investigations. In season 17, episode 16, titled "History Repeats Itself," Paula Zahn takes an in-depth look at a case that takes her back to her hometown of Canton, Ohio.

In this episode, we follow the investigation into the murder of 27-year-old Rachel Anderson. Anderson was a young mother who went missing from her home in December 2010. Her body was discovered two months later, partially buried in a shallow grave in a rural area outside of Canton.

As Zahn looks into the case, she discovers that there are many similarities between Rachel Anderson's murder and the murder of another young woman from Canton, named Tracy Kroh. Kroh went missing in August 1989 and her body was never found. However, investigators believe that she was also murdered.

Zahn interviews family members and friends of both women, as well as law enforcement officials who worked on the cases. She uncovers a web of secrets, lies, and possible suspects in both murders.

One key figure in the investigation is a man named John Carlin. Carlin was a suspect in Tracy Kroh's disappearance, and he also had a connection to Rachel Anderson. He was arrested and charged with Anderson's murder in 2012, but the case against him fell apart and he was released.

Zahn also looks at other potential suspects and explores the possibility that there may be a serial killer operating in Canton. She delves into the history of the city and its underworld, uncovering connections between different crimes and possible suspects.

Throughout the episode, Zahn explores the impact that these two unsolved murders have had on the families and communities involved. She looks at the ways in which these cases have changed the landscape of Canton, both physically and emotionally.

"History Repeats Itself" is a gripping episode of On The Case With Paula Zahn that offers a fascinating look at two interconnected murder cases and the people affected by them. Zahn's investigative approach and personal connection to the case make for compelling viewing, and the episode provides new insights into the ongoing search for justice for Rachel Anderson and Tracy Kroh.