Ep 10. Crime and Punishment

In Northern Exposure season 4 episode 10, titled "Crime and Punishment," the quirky residents of the small town of Cicely, Alaska are faced with a dilemma when a young man named Luke (played by guest star Kevin Tighe) arrives in town, claiming to be a former inmate who was wrongfully convicted of a crime. Luke's presence causes quite a stir, as he is eager to prove his innocence and clear his name, but the town is not quite sure who to believe.

As Luke begins to work odd jobs around town, he catches the eye of Maggie (played by Janine Turner), a local pilot and love interest of the show's protagonist, Dr. Joel Fleischman (played by Rob Morrow). Joel is initially skeptical of Luke's claims, but Maggie is more sympathetic and encourages Joel to help Luke in his quest for justice.

Meanwhile, tensions rise in Cicely as some residents fear that Luke's presence could put them in danger. Maurice (played by Barry Corbin), the town's wealthy former astronaut, is particularly outspoken in his opposition to Luke and his belief that he should be sent back to prison. However, not everyone is convinced of Luke's guilt, and Joel begins to investigate the case further.

As the episode progresses, Joel uncovers evidence that suggests Luke may be telling the truth, and he becomes increasingly determined to help him clear his name. However, he faces opposition from both Maurice and the local police, who are reluctant to reopen the case and admit that they may have made a mistake.

Despite the obstacles in his way, Joel perseveres and eventually uncovers the truth about the crime that Luke was accused of. The episode ends with a dramatic courtroom scene, as Luke's fate hangs in the balance and the truth is finally revealed.

Overall, "Crime and Punishment" is a thought-provoking and engaging episode of Northern Exposure, exploring themes of justice, redemption, and the power of community. As always, the show's ensemble cast shines, with standout performances from guest star Kevin Tighe and series regulars Rob Morrow, Janine Turner, and Barry Corbin.