Ep 1. Mr. Monk and the Other Detective
- TV-14
- July 8, 2005
- 43 min
-
8.0 (1,226)
Mr. Monk and the Other Detective is the season four premiere of the beloved comedy-drama television series Monk. The episode opens with a dramatic bank heist, complete with hostages, guns, and a daring escape. The SFPD is tasked with finding the culprits and bringing them to justice, but a new detective in town, Marty Eels, grabs the case and cuts off communication with Captain Stottlemeyer and his team.
This puts a roadblock in Monk's latest mission, which involves being reinstated as an official detective. As it turns out, the titular "other detective" played by Jason Gray-Stanford has a reputation for being a bit of a maverick and a glory hog, threatening to steal thunder from the OCD-afflicted private investigator (played masterfully by Tony Shalhoub). Monk is torn between his need to solve the crime and his desire to prove himself to his former colleagues.
As the investigation progresses, Monk finds himself at odds with Eels and his unorthodox methods. The two are constantly working against each other, each trying to one-up the other with their solutions to the many obstacles in their path. To make matters worse, Eels is also the only detective who manages to get close to Sharona, Monk's nurse and right-hand woman, which only intensifies the rivalry between the two men.
One of the best parts of the episode is the impressive chemistry between the two actors, Shalhoub and Gray-Stanford. Both are great at playing off each other's quirks and ticks, making for some truly hilarious moments. As always, Shalhoub's portrayal of Monk is both endearing and frustrating, as the detective's obsessive-compulsive tendencies constantly get in the way of his success.
The episode is also packed with plenty of twists and turns that keep the audience guessing until the very end. The bank heist is just the beginning of a complex mystery that involves double-crossing, stolen identities, and even a not-so-dead accomplice. Monk and Eels both find themselves in dangerous situations, and it's fun to see them work together (and against each other) to get out of them.
Despite their clashing personalities, Monk and Eels eventually find themselves making some progress on the case. And in a satisfying twist, they discover that the mastermind behind the heist is someone Monk has encountered before: the notorious mobster, Joey Gallo. This bombshell sets the stage for future episodes and promises that things are only going to get more complicated for our favorite OCD detective.
All in all, Mr. Monk and the Other Detective is a fantastic start to the fourth season of the show. The clever writing, great acting, and intriguing mystery make for a thoroughly entertaining hour of television. Whether you're a longtime fan or a newcomer to the series, this episode is a great one to start with and will leave you eager to see what comes next.