Ep 15. Choice Of Evils

In Law & Order season 16 episode 15, titled "Choice of Evils," the focus is on a complex murder investigation that is further complicated by the defendant's difficult family background. The episode begins with the murder of a wealthy businessman named Alex Zuckerman. His wife, Naomi, is found unconscious in their home, leading detectives to suspect that she is the killer. However, their investigation reveals a web of lies and secrets that make it difficult to determine who is truly responsible for the crime.

The detectives discover that Naomi and Alex had a troubled marriage, with both parties having affairs and hidden financial dealings. They also uncover the fact that Alex's business dealings were not always ethical, which gives them a pool of potential suspects. As they delve deeper into the case, they come across Naomi's troubled upbringing, including a history of abuse and neglect. The detectives believe that this may have pushed her to commit the crime, but they must find concrete evidence to support their theory.

As the case progresses, the detectives discover that the victim's brother, who is a respected judge, might have played a role in the murder. They investigate him thoroughly, but it becomes clear that he is only a witness to the crime, not a perpetrator. Meanwhile, Naomi struggles with her conscience as she is torn between admitting her guilt and protecting her children, who she fears will be taken away from her if she is convicted.

As the case goes to trial, the prosecutor and defense attorneys exchange verbal jabs as each tries to prove their case. The jury is left to decide whether Naomi acted out of self-defense or malice. When the verdict is finally reached, it brings a sense of closure to the case, but leaves some questions unanswered. The detectives are left wondering whether justice was truly served and whether anyone else may have played a role in the crime.

"Choice of Evils" is a powerful episode that explores the complex emotions and motivations behind murder. It tackles issues such as domestic abuse, financial greed, and the lengths to which one will go to protect their family. The episode is a reminder that the law is not always black and white, and that there is no clear-cut answer when it comes to matters of life and death. With strong performances from the cast and tight direction, this episode is a standout in the Law & Order canon.