Ep 21. The Return of Jimmy Blackhorse

In JAG season 3 episode 21, titled "The Return of Jimmy Blackhorse," viewers are taken on a journey where a man named Jimmy Blackhorse, a Native American, is accused of murdering his commanding officer during a training exercise. Blackhorse doesn't remember what happened, and a military court has to figure out whether he is guilty or not.

As the episode progresses, both sides present their arguments, with the prosecution arguing that Blackhorse knowingly killed his commander, while the defense suggests that he was suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and had a blackout. Along the way, viewers get an insight into Blackhorse's background and the prejudices he has experienced as a Native American serving in the military.

The crux of the episode hinges on whether or not Blackhorse was capable of forming the intent to kill. The prosecution argues that he had a history of insubordination and was motivated by anger, while the defense tries to prove that he had no memory of the incident and was not capable of making a conscious decision to kill.

Throughout the episode, tensions are high between Blackhorse and his defense lawyer, Lt. Harmon Rabb, Jr., who believes that Blackhorse is guilty but still wants to defend him to the best of his ability. Meanwhile, the prosecution is represented by Lt. Cmdr. Joanne Galloway, who believes that Blackhorse is guilty and is determined to secure a conviction.

As the trial progresses, twists and turns keep viewers on their toes. Witnesses are questioned and cross-examined, and evidence is presented both for and against Blackhorse. Ultimately, the decision about Blackhorse's fate falls on the military judge, and viewers are left wondering what the verdict will be.

The episode raises important questions about the treatment of minority groups in the military, as well as the complex nature of PTSD and its effects on those who suffer from it. It also highlights the challenges faced by defense lawyers, who must balance their duty to their clients with their own beliefs about guilt or innocence.

In the end, "The Return of Jimmy Blackhorse" is a gripping episode that keeps viewers engaged from start to finish. With its thought-provoking themes and well-developed characters, it is a standout installment in the third season of JAG.