Ep 10. A Matter of Life and Death

In this suspenseful episode of I AM A KILLER, viewers are taken inside the mind of Brandon Hutchison, a man who has been on death row for over a decade. Hutchison was just 20 years old when he was convicted of killing 22-year-old Stacie Reed and her 46-year-old mother, Karen Winslett. The crime took place in 2003 in Fulton County, Georgia.

Throughout the episode, viewers hear from Hutchison himself as well as prison staff, investigators, and family members of the victims. Hutchison tells his side of the story, explaining how he ended up at the Winslett home on the night of the murders. He claims that he was there to retrieve money owed to him by Stacie Reed's boyfriend and that he had no intention of harming anyone.

However, the evidence presented at trial tells a different story. Forensic evidence showed that Hutchison had tied up and gagged both women before stabbing them repeatedly. Hutchison's DNA was found on the murder weapon, and his clothes were stained with the victims' blood. When questioned by investigators, he could not provide a clear motive for the killings.

Despite overwhelming evidence against him, Hutchison maintains his innocence. He argues that he was coerced into confessing to the crime and that the evidence against him was planted by corrupt police officers. However, multiple courts have reviewed the case and upheld Hutchison's conviction.

As viewers listen to Hutchison's story, they are forced to grapple with the question of whether or not he deserves to live. Although he has been on death row for over a decade, his execution has been repeatedly postponed due to legal challenges. Some argue that he should be given clemency and allowed to live out the rest of his life in prison. Others believe that he deserves the ultimate punishment for his heinous crimes.

Ultimately, A Matter of Life and Death is a thought-provoking episode that raises important questions about justice, accountability, and the death penalty. Through intimate interviews with the people closest to the case, viewers are given a rare glimpse into the complexities of a capital murder trial and the toll it takes on everyone involved.