Ep 3. Head in the Oven

In the third episode of season 5 of Fear Thy Neighbor, entitled "Head in the Oven," viewers are taken to Birmingham, Alabama where two neighbors experience a tumultuous relationship that ultimately ends in tragedy.

The episode focuses on the neighborly dispute between 66-year-old Vietnam War veteran Norbert Kinnaman and his 55-year-old neighbor Danny Lee Miller. The two lived next door to each other for over a decade, but things turned sour when Miller allegedly started harassing Kinnaman and his wife, Beryl, over property lines and loud music.

The tension between the two escalates one summer evening when Miller invites Kinnaman over for a drink. Kinnaman declines the invitation, stating that he doesn't want to drink with Miller because he's too mean when he's drunk. Enraged by the rejection, Miller allegedly breaks into Kinnaman's house later that night and smashes his wife's favorite vase.

The incident leaves Kinnaman shaken and afraid for his safety. He installs surveillance cameras around his property and starts carrying a gun for protection. However, his fears are realized one fall evening when Miller enters his home and fatally shoots him before putting his head in the oven.

The episode examines the events leading up to the murder, delving into the history between the two neighbors and exploring the possible motives behind Miller's violent outburst. It also features interviews with members of the local community who knew both men and sheds light on the impact the tragedy had on those closest to Kinnaman.

Throughout the episode, viewers are left wondering what exactly caused Miller, a seemingly ordinary man with no previous criminal history, to commit such a heinous act. As the investigation unfolds, viewers are presented with a complex web of conflicting stories and motives, leaving them on the edge of their seats until the very end.

"Head in the Oven" is a gripping true crime story that explores the destructive power of neighborly disputes gone wrong. Through interviews with witnesses, family members, and law enforcement, the episode offers a glimpse into the tragic events that occur when tensions between neighbors escalate into violence.