Ep 5. Thick as Thieves

The episode "Thick as Thieves" from the fifth season of the television show Cold Case explores the aftermath of a fatal armored car robbery that occurred in Philadelphia back in 1999. Detective Lilly Rush (played by Kathryn Morris) and her team are assigned the task of investigating the crime which remains unsolved even after a decade.

The case is reopened when a new witness comes forward. He is Jimmy Bruno, a former member of the gang who pulled off the robbery. Bruno claims to have information that could potentially solve the case. He provides the police with an account of the robbery, describing the events that took place and the people who were involved. His testimony helps the detectives to identify the members of the gang and the mastermind behind the robbery.

As the investigation progresses, the detectives begin to discover a web of deceit and betrayal that surrounds the case. They uncover links between the robbers and a corrupt detective who was involved in the case. The detectives also learn more about the personal lives of the robbers, their motivations for the crime, and the circumstances that led them down a path of crime.

Meanwhile, throughout the investigation, Detective Rush finds herself constantly struggling to keep her personal life separate from her work. She is forced to confront her own demons as she reflects on her relationship with her husband Eddie (played by Thom Barry) and her own sense of identity. Her personal issues serve as a backdrop to the investigation and add an emotional depth to the episode.

As the detectives delve deeper into the case, they uncover more clues that lead them closer to solving the crime. They track down the members of the gang and one by one, they start to piece together the details of the robbery. However, not everything is as it seems, and a shocking twist changes everything.

The episode "Thick as Thieves" is a classic Cold Case story that explores themes of loyalty, betrayal, and the complexities of human relationships. The episode's plot is well-crafted and keeps the viewer guessing until the very end. The performances by the cast are excellent, with Kathryn Morris delivering a standout performance as Detective Lilly Rush.

Overall, the episode is a must-watch for fans of the show and anyone who enjoys a good crime drama. It is a testament to the show's enduring popularity and success, and it remains one of the standout episodes of the fifth season.