Ep 6. The Sleepover

The episode "The Sleepover" in season 2 of Cold Case revolves around the murder of an affluent teenager named Holly.

The episode begins with a flashback to 1994, when 15-year-old Holly is having a sleepover with her friends. They are drinking and chatting when a boy named Oliver arrives at the house. Holly is immediately smitten with him and invites him to join the party. The group continues to drink and eventually falls asleep.

The next morning, Holly's parents come home to find her dead in her bed. The investigation is initially ruled a suicide, as Holly had taken pills and left a note. However, when the detective assigned to the case, John Stillman, takes a closer look, he realizes that there are inconsistencies in the evidence that point to foul play.

Stillman puts together a team to re-investigate Holly's death, led by detective Lilly Rush. As the team delves deeper into the case, they discover that Holly's friends may have been more involved in her death than they initially let on. They interview Oliver, who is now a wealthy businessman, and he tells them that he left the sleepover early and didn't see anything suspicious.

The team also discovers that Holly's sister, who had been away at college at the time, had a tumultuous relationship with Holly and was jealous of her popularity. They interview her and find out that the night of the sleepover, she had been out drinking with a group of her own friends. Stillman and Rush suspect that she may have come home and had a confrontation with Holly.

As the team continues to investigate, they uncover a web of lies and secrets that lead them closer to the truth. They interview Holly's former boyfriend, who had a history of violence and may have had a motive to harm her. They also discover that one of Holly's friends had been stealing from her and was desperate to keep it a secret.

The episode culminates in a dramatic twist that reveals the true perpetrator of Holly's murder. The team is able to bring the killer to justice and provide closure for Holly's family.

Overall, "The Sleepover" is a riveting and emotional episode that explores the all-too-realistic consequences of teenage jealousy and betrayal. It showcases the meticulous investigative skills of the Cold Case team and their determination to bring justice to victims and their families.