Ep 21. Creatures of the Night

In Season 2 Episode 21 of Cold Case titled "Creatures of the Night," the team is tasked with solving the murder of a young woman named Sally, who was found dead in the woods in 1988 after attending a Halloween party. The investigation begins with a visit to the high school where Sally and her friends went to school, and the team soon discovers that Sally was involved in some risky behavior, including drug use and sexual experimentation.

As the team digs deeper into Sally's life, they uncover a web of secrets and lies that lead them to believe that her murder may have been connected to the occult. Sally’s friends film their own horror movies and experiment with Satanism, and it’s clear that they may know more about the murder than they’re letting on. The team talks to several of Sally’s friends, and they all seem to be hiding something.

One of the suspects is Sally’s ex-boyfriend, who had a rocky relationship with her and may have been jealous of her interest in another man. Another possible suspect is a man who was seen leaving the party with Sally, and who may have been involved in the occult activities that she and her friends were experimenting with.

Throughout the investigation, the team learns more about Sally’s background and the circumstances that led to her murder. They find that her parents were distant and often absent, leaving her vulnerable to experimentation and the influence of her friends. They also discover that Sally may have been struggling with mental health issues, which could have played a role in her decision-making.

The team finally pieces together enough evidence to make an arrest, but the case takes a shocking turn when they learn that the killer may not be who they thought. It’s a surprise twist that keeps the audience on the edge of their seat until the very end.

Overall, “Creatures of the Night” is a thrilling and thought-provoking episode that explores the darker side of teenage experimentation and the occult. The episode features strong performances from all of the actors involved, particularly the young cast members who bring a sense of realism and authenticity to the high school scenes. The episode’s mystery is well-crafted, with plenty of red herrings and surprising plot twists to keep the audience guessing. And, as with all episodes of Cold Case, the ending is emotionally satisfying and provides closure for the victim’s family.