Ep 9. Murder by Moonlight

The 10th season of Cold Case Files continues with its 9th episode, "Murder by Moonlight," where it follows the story of a gruesome triple homicide that took place near the town of Little Falls in New York in the summer of 1990.

The police arrived on the scene to find two women and a teenage boy dead. The crime had been committed in the middle of the night, and the victims had been bludgeoned to death with a baseball bat. The case was particularly difficult because there didn't seem to be a clear motive, a suspect, or any physical evidence that could lead to an arrest. The case went cold for three years until one day, the police received an anonymous letter. It revealed a clue that finally led to a break in the case.

The episode delves into the investigation of the homicide, tracing how the police followed the lead found in the anonymous letter and found a possible suspect: a man named Rick J. Thibodeau. Police found Thibodeau's car abandoned near the crime scene, and they soon began digging into his past. Who is Rick J. Thibodeau, and why does he have a connection to the town?

As the investigation progresses, detectives unravel various leads and discover a web of secrets, lies, and betrayals that seemingly connect Thibodeau to the murders. One theory even suggests that Thibodeau killed the victims during a drug deal gone wrong.

The episode features interviews from family members of the victims, as well as retired detectives and law enforcement officials who share their perspectives on the case. They recount their experiences during the investigation, the overwhelming evidence against Thibodeau, and the difficulties they faced as they tried to uncover the truth.

Although the episode eerily relies on the possibility that the killer might still be out there, the host reminds viewers that Thibodeau was already convicted and sentenced to prison. This case demonstrates how crucial it is to not give up on a case no matter how cold it may seem and how eventually justice can be served.

Overall, "Murder by Moonlight" is an intriguing episode that provides a detailed account of a cold case and the painstaking investigative work that led to an arrest. Viewers can expect to be enthralled with a suspenseful plot that unravels slowly throughout the episode, with twists and turns that keep them hooked until the end.