Ep 5. The Closers/Caught by an Eyelash

In season 5, episode 5 of Cold Case Files Classic, titled "The Closers/Caught by an Eyelash," viewers are taken on a journey to revisit two intriguing cases that were solved with the help of creative detective work.

The first case, "The Closers," chronicles the 1988 murder of 38-year-old Carolyn Cox in Matewan, West Virginia. The case remained unsolved for over a decade until two tenacious detectives, Mike Sizemore and Ronnie Vance, took on the case and dubbed themselves "The Closers." Despite the lack of evidence and witnesses, the detectives used their expertise to meticulously gather information and piece together the crime scene. By recreating the events leading up to Cox's death, they were able to solve the case and bring justice to the victim's family.

The second case, "Caught by an Eyelash," takes viewers to the streets of New York City in 1980s. The case revolves around the murder of 19-year-old Lisa D'Addio, who was found dead in her apartment. The perpetrator had left behind only a few hairs and a single eyelash, which was analyzed by forensic expert Dr. Robert Shaler. Despite the lack of solid evidence, Dr. Shaler used cutting-edge technology to map out the killer's DNA. With this vital piece of information in hand, the detectives were able to solve the case and bring the perpetrator to justice.

Both cases showcased the power of detective work in solving seemingly unsolvable cases. The dedication and perseverance of the detectives involved ultimately led to justice for the victims and their families. Viewers are left with a sense of awe and admiration for the remarkable work done by these detectives and forensic experts.