Ep 12. Cro-Magnon

Ally McBeal season 1 episode 12 titled "Cro-Magnon" follows the law firm of Cage and Fish as it takes on a case of a man who claims to be a Cro-Magnon living in present-day Boston. While the episode has its fair share of the trademark quirkiness of the show, it also delves into some serious themes, such as mental illness and societal norms.

The episode opens with John Cage, the eccentric and slightly off-kilter managing partner of the firm, admitting a new client, Mr. Hanson. Mr. Hanson tells Cage that he is a Cro-Magnon, and that he deserves to be treated differently because of the differences in his genetics. Of course, Ally McBeal, the show's titular character, is less than convinced by this claim. As the case progresses, Hanson continues to behave erratically and make claims that the other lawyers in the firm find hard to believe.

As the case builds to a climax, the lawyers at Cage and Fish are forced to confront their own biases and preconceptions about mental illness and what is considered "normal" behavior. At the same time, the audience is given a glimpse into the inner workings of the human mind and how mental illness can manifest in ways that are hard for outsiders to understand.

In typical Ally McBeal fashion, the episode is peppered with surreal touches, such as Hanson's costume and the way he interacts with those around him. However, the underlying message is a serious one: that society tends to exclude and marginalize those who don't fit neatly into its preconceived categories, whether it be due to race, gender, sexuality, or mental health.

Despite tackling some heavy themes, "Cro-Magnon" manages to maintain the show's signature blend of drama and humor. Particularly noteworthy is the performance of Peter MacNicol, who plays John Cage with a mix of vulnerability and quirkiness that has become a hallmark of the show. Calista Flockhart also shines as Ally McBeal, struggling to balance her own doubts about Hanson's claims with her desire to provide the best possible defense for her client.

All in all, "Cro-Magnon" is a standout episode of a show that was known for pushing the boundaries of what was considered acceptable on TV at the time. By using the character of Mr. Hanson to explore some complex issues around mental health and societal norms, the writers of Ally McBeal showed that it was possible to tackle important themes while still producing a show that was entertaining and engaging. Fans of the show are sure to appreciate this episode for its wit, its heart, and its unflinching look at some of the darker corners of the human psyche.