Watch The Incoherents

The Incoherents is a 2019 independent comedy-drama film directed by Jared Barel and starring Annette O'Toole, Amy Carlson, and Kate Arrington. The film follows a group of middle-aged friends who decide to reunite their garage band from their youth in the hopes of finally making it big. Jeff (played by Jeff Auer) is a married father who feels stuck in his corporate job and yearns for the excitement of his past as a guitarist in a band. His old bandmates, including his ex-girlfriend Kate (played by Arrington), are living similarly unfulfilling lives, so Jeff convinces them to reunite the band. They recruit a drummer named Spyder (Alex Emanuel) to complete their lineup.

At first, their performances are disasters, but they eventually begin to gel musically and emotionally. They practice in Jeff's garage, obsessively perfecting their sound and working to write new songs. While Jeff's wife Karen and his daughter are supportive, Kate's husband Mike (Robert McKay) is skeptical of the band's chances and the toll it will take on their family.

As they begin to book gigs, the band faces new challenges: Jeff struggles with stage fright, Kate must deal with unwanted advances from the band's sleazy manager (Jerry O'Connell), and the three men's egos clash. Additionally, they must negotiate their relationships with one another as they confront the realities of aging and changing priorities.

The Incoherents is a heartfelt film that captures the struggles of balancing passion and responsibility in middle age. The characters are relatable and well-drawn, with each band member facing their own unique obstacles on the road to rock 'n' roll glory. The film deftly balances comedy with drama, bringing levity to some of the more serious moments.

The performances are uniformly excellent, with O'Toole, Carlson, and Arrington in particular shining as the three primary band members. The chemistry between the actors is palpable, and their musical performances are authentic and energetic.

Overall, The Incoherents is a satisfying and entertaining film that will resonate with anyone who has ever dreamed of being in a band. It is a testament to the enduring power of music and its ability to bring people together, even in the face of seemingly insurmountable odds.

The Incoherents is a 2020 comedy with a runtime of 1 hour and 49 minutes. It has received mostly poor reviews from critics and viewers, who have given it an IMDb score of 4.9.