Watch The Argumentative Indian

The movie "The Argumentative Indian" is a thought-provoking and insightful documentary that explores the rich intellectual heritage of India and the deep traditions of argument and debate that have shaped the country's past and continue to influence its future. Released in 2018, this documentary offers a nuanced and comprehensive examination of the complex social, cultural, and political issues that define India.

Directed by Suman Ghosh, "The Argumentative Indian" takes its inspiration from the acclaimed book of the same name by Nobel laureate Amartya Sen. The film seeks to bring Sen's ideas to life by blending interviews, archival footage, and captivating discussions with intellectuals, scholars, and everyday citizens.

The documentary is divided into various thematic segments, each exploring a different aspect of Indian society. It starts by delving into the deep roots of argument and debate in Indian history, tracing them back to ancient philosophical traditions that valued discussions and differing opinions. The film then delves into the debates surrounding identity, secularism, and religious tolerance in contemporary India, shedding light on the complexities and challenges faced by a diverse nation grappling with its own multicultural fabric.

Through interviews with prominent figures such as Amartya Sen, Nobel laureate economist, and Ela Bhatt, renowned social activist and founder of Self-Employed Women's Association (SEWA), "The Argumentative Indian" draws on their expertise to delve into issues of inequality, poverty, and the paradoxes that India faces. The film examines India's journey since independence and reflects on the successes and failures in its pursuit of social justice and economic progress.

"The Argumentative Indian" also highlights the importance of language and literature in shaping Indian society. It examines the works of influential writers and thinkers such as Rabindranath Tagore, Bankim Chandra Chattopadhyay, and Mahasweta Devi, emphasizing how their writings have been central to arguing for social reforms, justice, and equality. The film underlines their contribution to India's cultural and intellectual landscape, showcasing how literature can illuminate and challenge societal norms.

Furthermore, the documentary explores the connection between democracy and argumentation in India. It brings to light the crucial role of freedom of speech, expression, and dissent in fostering a robust democracy. The film discusses pivotal events in Indian history, such as the Emergency imposed in the 1970s, which posed a threat to these fundamental democratic values. Through personal anecdotes and expert analysis, it demonstrates how argumentation and dialogue have been crucial in preserving democracy and defending citizens' rights.

"The Argumentative Indian" also encompasses contemporary debates surrounding nationalism and regionalism. It investigates issues of identity politics, language conflicts, and historical narratives, providing a comprehensive view of the challenges that arise when different groups assert their cultural and linguistic distinctiveness. By showcasing the diverse perspectives and voices across the nation, the film attempts to foster greater understanding and dialogue among Indians.

Overall, "The Argumentative Indian" is an engaging and enlightening documentary that encourages viewers to contemplate the complexities and paradoxes of India's social, cultural, and political landscape. It navigates through a myriad of topics, from history and literature to democracy and nationalism, with a keen focus on the power of argumentation and dialogue in shaping societies. By highlighting the traditions that have defined India, the film prompts viewers to question, appreciate, and engage in debates that ultimately contribute to the nation's progress and development.

The Argumentative Indian is a 2017 documentary with a runtime of 56 minutes.